Weblog: Manipur Disaster – When Hill-Valley “Divide” Reaches Tipping Level

Violence has damaged out throughout BJP-ruled Manipur between the Meiteis and Kukis. The federal government within the northeast state has issued a shoot-at-sight order and has snapped cellular web to defuse tensions and management the spiralling violence.

Movies present properties burning, even within the state capital Imphal, the place the scenario is now calm after violence broke out in Churachandpur district, 65 km from the valley metropolis of seven lakh folks.


What precisely is going on in Manipur?

There are broadly two components that led to dormant anger manifesting in violence within the state that has largely left behind its insurgency-tainted previous.

First, the BJP authorities led by Chief Minister N Biren Singh, who’s a Meitei, has destroyed massive tracts of poppy fields within the tribal-dominated hills and has evicted alleged unlawful immigrants from reserved forests to crack down on the narcotics commerce. This has brought about deep resentment amongst tribals, notably the Kukis, who alleged church buildings and houses that weren’t unlawful building, too, have been razed within the state authorities’s “struggle on medicine” marketing campaign.

Second, the Meiteis, who’re Hindus and traditionally have been beneath the “basic” class, have been demanding to be categorised as Scheduled Tribes (ST). This has alarmed tribals, who’re ST, as Meiteis turning into ST from “basic” would stretch authorities advantages which might be reserved for ST in jobs and different areas.

Briefly, the basis explanation for the disaster in Manipur is the results of the communities’ nervousness over the share of sources.


A majority of the Meiteis – who’re Hindus – dwell in Imphal valley and surrounding areas, however few Meiteis dwell in hill areas of the 16 districts within the state. The tribals – who’re Christians – together with Kukis, Nagas and different communities, are the bulk in virtually all hill areas in Manipur.

The composition of political events and leaders within the Manipur authorities for many years has been largely Meitei-dominated. This created an uneasy scenario of a hill-valley divide, or in different phrases, a tribal-Meitei divide, whether or not perceived or not, for many years. The present disaster is the results of this uneasy scenario coming to a head.

Many tribal MLAs, nonetheless, have all the time been a part of the federal government and performed kingmakers in forming governments. Even former Chief Minister Rishang Keishing, who belonged to the Congress occasion, was a Tangkhul Naga, not a Meitei.


A piece of the Meiteis, who need to be categorised as ST, has cited two key factors to again the demand.

First, they are saying there are numerous financially weak Meiteis, as in some other neighborhood, who’re at an obstacle after they compete within the “basic” class.

Second, this part of Meiteis – citing their tradition earlier than they have been transformed to Hinduism within the early 18th century, particularly Vaishnavism – say they don’t seem to be so totally different from tribals, solely that they have been transformed from their animistic faith ‘Sanamahism’ to a significant faith whose syncretic model they observe now.

The tribals, nonetheless, are satisfied the arguments by this part of Meiteis are solely excuses to seize authorities advantages meant for ST. The tribals say the Meiteis have loved political and financial energy in Manipur for a very long time, however because the inhabitants will increase and sources grow to be restricted, the Meiteis need easy accessibility to advantages, even at the price of rejecting the “basic” class and shedding their perceived maintain on state affairs.

The opposite speedy set off of the present disaster is the destruction of poppy plantations in hill areas.


The Manipur authorities has destroyed 1000’s of acres of poppy plantations within the hills since 2017, when the primary time period of the BJP started in Manipur. Japanese Manipur’s 5 districts share a 400-km border with Myanmar and fewer than 10 per cent of its worldwide border with Myanmar is fenced, leaving the area extensive open for drug smuggling. Poppy cultivation is a significant difficulty in 5 hill districts of Manipur – Ukhrul, Senapati, Kangpokpi, Kamjong, Tengnoupal and Churachandpur. Rising this plant in distant areas within the hills ensures a simple supply of revenue as it’s utilized in making medicine, together with morphine.

Amid rigidity over lands and livelihoods, the demolition of some church buildings in Imphal valley – which the authorities mentioned have been unlawful building – gave a communal tone to the matter and drew battle strains between the Hindu Meiteis and the Christian tribals.

The fuse of this powder keg was lit in April, when the Manipur Excessive Courtroom advised the BJP-led state authorities to ship a request to the centre to verify if Meiteis might be categorised as ST.

Completely different tribes, together with the Kukis and Nagas who had bitterly fought towards one another previously, coalesced round their frequent religion and referred to as a “united tribal protest” towards the state authorities, which they see as predominantly Meitei.

The energetic contributors within the present disaster, nonetheless, are solely a bit of the Kukis and Meiteis, whose actions have dragged of their total communities.


Many tribals apart from Kukis, such because the Nagas in Manipur, have objected to being clubbed collectively as “tribals” within the context of the protest as they are saying they don’t seem to be collaborating on the streets.

Equally, solely a bit of the Meiteis needs to be categorised as ST. Most Meiteis need to be within the “basic” class and retain their syncretic identification, i.e. a mix of the animist Sanamahism and Hinduism.

What seems to be hate-fuelled ethnic rigidity on the floor is basically the insecurity amongst communities for a very good future as an increasing number of folks make claims on restricted sources and advantages.

(Debanish Achom is Editor, Information, at NDTV)

Disclaimer: These are the non-public opinions of the creator.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Read More