Why are people drawn to artwork that mixes disappointment and wonder? A mind scientist says disappointment has advantages like serving to elicit empathy and purging detrimental emotion.
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
Disappointment is greater than only a detrimental emotion. It may be stunning.
(SOUNDBITE OF CLIFF MASTERSON’S “BEAUTIFUL SADNESS”)
SUMMERS: NPR’s Jon Hamilton appears to be like at why we’re drawn to artwork that mixes disappointment and wonder.
(SOUNDBITE OF CLIFF MASTERSON’S “BEAUTIFUL SADNESS”)
JON HAMILTON, BYLINE: This adagio was composed by Cliff Masterson, who lives and works in London.
CLIFF MASTERSON: After I wrote it, the kind of feeling of the music was unhappy, however but there was this stunning melody that sat on prime.
HAMILTON: It is referred to as “Stunning Disappointment.” And Masterson says it follows the principles of musical melancholy – lengthy, gradual phrases, chords that keep in a slim vary.
MASTERSON: Clearly, it is in a minor key, and it by no means strays removed from that minor key house place.
HAMILTON: It even includes a violin – the orchestral expression of human sorrow.
(SOUNDBITE OF CLIFF MASTERSON’S “BEAUTIFUL SADNESS”)
MASTERSON: It is one of many few devices the place I believe you may get a lot persona. The intonation is totally yours. The vibrato is totally yours. And it may be very a lot a voice within the orchestra.
HAMILTON: But all of those efforts to evoke disappointment are additionally meant to entice a listener. In any case, Masterson composed this piece for Audio Community, a service that gives music to purchasers like Netflix and Pepsi.
MASTERSON: There’s a variety of unhappy songs on the market – kind of very unhappy music. And other people take pleasure in listening to it, they usually get a pleasure from it, I believe.
HAMILTON: As a result of the disappointment is part of one thing stunning. Matt Sachs is a mind scientist at Columbia College who research this phenomenon.
MATT SACHS: Pleasurable disappointment is what we name it – this attraction to this detrimental emotion that we’re type of designed to need to keep away from in on a regular basis life. However in aesthetics and in artwork, we actively search it out.
HAMILTON: One thing artists have identified just about eternally. Within the 1800s, the poet John Keats wrote concerning the story of pleasing woe. Within the Nineties, songwriter Tom Waits named an album “Stunning Maladies.” Sachs says there are causes our species developed a style for pleasurable disappointment.
SACHS: It permits us to expertise the advantages that disappointment brings, resembling eliciting empathy, resembling connecting with others, resembling purging a detrimental emotion, with out really having to undergo the loss that’s usually related to it.
HAMILTON: Sachs says vicarious disappointment could make an individual extra reasonable.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “MISS MISERY”)
ELLIOTT SMITH: (Singing) I am going to faux it via the day.
HAMILTON: And it will probably carry solace.
SACHS: After I’m unhappy and I take heed to Elliott Smith, I really feel much less alone. I really feel like he understands what I am going via, and that connection is then the psychological profit or the primary factor.
HAMILTON: Pleasurable disappointment seems to be most pronounced in individuals with a lot of empathy, particularly a element of empathy generally known as fantasy. This refers to an individual’s skill to establish intently with fictional characters in a story.
SACHS: And despite the fact that music does not all the time have a robust narrative or a robust character, this class of empathy tends to be very strongly correlated with the having fun with of unhappy music.
HAMILTON: Cliff Masterson, the composer, says in films, music can really propel a story and tackle a persona.
MASTERSON: Composers, significantly within the final 30 or 40 years, have finished a unbelievable job of being that unseen character in movies.
HAMILTON: Masterson says that is clearly the case within the film “E.T.,” the place director Steven Spielberg labored intently with composer John Williams.
MASTERSON: Even now, , on the ripe previous age I’m, I can not watch that movie with out crying. And it is loads to do with the music.
(SOUNDBITE OF JOHN WILLIAMS’ “LOSING E.T.”)
HAMILTON: Pleasurable disappointment is even current in comedies, just like the animated collection, “South Park.” Take the scene the place the character Butters, a fourth-grader, has simply been dumped by his girlfriend. The goth children attempt to console him.
(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SOUTH PARK”)
MATT STONE: (As Goth Child #1) I assume you’ll be able to be part of up with us if you’d like.
TREY PARKER: (As Goth Child #2) Yeah. We’ll go to the graveyard and write poems about dying and the way pointless life is.
HAMILTON: Butters says, no thanks. He values his disappointment.
(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SOUTH PARK”)
STONE: (As Butters) It makes me really feel alive, ? It makes me really feel human. The one manner I may really feel this proper now could be if I felt one thing actually good earlier than. So I’ve to take the dangerous with the great. So I assume what I am feeling is sort of a stunning disappointment. I assume that sounds silly.
HAMILTON: Or perhaps profound.
Jon Hamilton, NPR Information.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “FAMILY”)
DAR WILLIAMS: (Singing) Are you able to repair this? It is a damaged coronary heart. It was advantageous, nevertheless it simply fell aside. It was mine, however now I give it to you. ‘Trigger you’ll be able to repair it. You recognize what to do. Let your love cowl me like a pair of angel wings. You might be my household.
Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content might not be in its remaining type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could range. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
