Jalapeno Popper Grilled Cheese | The Recipe Critic


This web site might comprise affiliate hyperlinks and promoting in order that we are able to present recipes to you. Learn my privateness coverage.

Add some kick to a basic consolation meal with this insanely good jalapeno popper grilled cheese! It’s full of melty colby jack, bacon, spicy jalapeños, and cream cheese to stability the warmth and add creaminess. You’re going to adore it!

Searching for extra enjoyable twists on a basic grilled cheese? Do that pizza grilled cheese or sloppy joe grilled cheese subsequent!

3 slices of jalapeno popper grilled cheeses stacked on top of each other.

Jalapeno Popper Grilled Cheese Recipe

Everyone loves a great jalapeno popper, so why not take these flavors and add them to a different basic consolation meals? I LOVE grilled cheeses, and didn’t actually assume they may get any higher. However including spicy jalapenos, cool cream cheese, and bacon does simply that! It’s the grilled cheese improve you by no means knew you wanted.

You can also make your grilled cheese on a skillet as per regular, or make it within the air fryer for straightforward prep. (Personally, that is my favourite solution to make it! It seems so crispy and divine!) Both approach, you’re going to like this tacky, spicy, bacon-filled goodness.

Substances You’ll Want

Like every home made sandwich, be at liberty to swap out the bread, cheese, or toppings to make it simply the best way you prefer it! The precise measurements I used to make my jalapeno popper grilled cheese are within the recipe card under.

  • Jalapeños: These spicy peppers present a kick of warmth and taste, giving the grilled cheese a signature jalapeño popper style. Yum!
  • Olive Oil: The olive oil helps sauté the jalapeños, enhancing their taste and making them tender.
  • Cream Cheese: Cream cheese provides a creamy and tangy aspect to the filling, harking back to conventional jalapeño poppers.
  • Inexperienced Onions: Diced so as to add some gentle onion taste.
  • Garlic Powder: For slightly additional savory goodness. You may as well use roasted garlic!
  • Colby-Jack Cheese: The shredded Colby-Jack cheese brings gooeyness and a wealthy mix of flavors.
  • Bacon: Crispy bacon provides a smoky and salty aspect to the jalapeno popper grilled cheese. Use precooked bacon for straightforward prep!
  • Bread: I often go for French bread or sourdough, however you need to use any type you need.
  • Butter: Softened butter is unfold on the bread to attain a golden and crispy exterior throughout grilling.
  • Garlic Salt (Non-compulsory): If used, garlic salt can add an additional layer of garlic taste and seasoning to the sandwich.
  • Italian Seasoning (Non-compulsory): My favourite mix of herbs! They offer the jalapeno popper grilled cheese additional taste and make it odor superb.

How one can Make a Jalapeno Popper Grilled Cheese Sandwich

It’s simply as simple as making a basic grilled cheese. The one additional step is to roast your jalapenos to essentially carry out their scrumptious taste!

  1. Roast Your Jalapenos: Preheat the oven to broil. Place the entire jalapenos on a baking sheet then drizzle with olive oil. Broil for 5-6 minutes turning midway by. Watch the jalapenos intently, they could broil faster relying in your oven.
  2. Enable Jalapenos to Sweat: Place the roasted jalapenos in a ziplock bag to “sweat” for five minutes.
  3. Take away Pores and skin and Seeds: Take away the pores and skin and minimize every jalapeno in half lengthwise. Then discard the seeds.
  4. Cream Cheese Combination: In a medium bowl, mix the cream cheese, inexperienced onion, and garlic powder. 
  5. Add Unfold: Unfold the cream cheese combination on one aspect of all 4 slices of bread.
  6. Layer With Toppings: Prime two of the slices with shredded cheese, and the opposite two slices with bacon and roasted jalapenos.
  7. Butter: Rigorously shut the sandwich and butter the highest slice of bread. Then add a sprinkle of garlic salt and Italian seasoning in the event you want. 
  8. Warmth Skillet: Warmth a big nonstick skillet over medium warmth. Then place the buttered aspect down on the skillet and shortly butter and season the topside. 
  9. Prepare dinner: Prepare dinner for about 4 minutes per aspect or till golden brown. Flip the warmth down if the skin begins to brown too shortly. Low and sluggish is the important thing to melting the cheese and never getting the skin too darkish.
4-photo collage of the jalapenos being roasted and the sandwich assembled.

Ideas and Variations

Listed here are a couple of ideas, tips, and variations in order that your jalapeno popper grilled cheese seems as tasty as doable! Belief me, upon getting a grilled cheese like this you gained’t need it some other approach.

  • Wash Your Palms: Wash your fingers completely after working with jalapeno peppers. Particularly after eradicating the seeds as a result of they will irritate the pores and skin. Take away fewer seeds in the event you prefer it actually spicy!
  • Roasting Jalapenos: Watch the jalapenos intently as they broil. They’ll get darkish fairly quick!
  • Swap Up the Cheese: I LOVE Colby-Jack cheese on this sandwich however be at liberty to make use of any type of cheese. Cheddar, Monterey Jack, American, and provolone are all nice choices.
  • Use Any Bread: Sourdough bread is my favourite, however you need to use white or wheat bread as properly. Bakery-style bread would even be scrumptious equivalent to Italian bread or artisan bread.
  • Bacon: Use pre-cooked bacon as a result of you may make the sandwich faster!
  • Low and Sluggish: Decrease warmth is the trick to a great grilled cheese. It slowly melts the cheese, however doesn’t burn the bread too quick.

Two halves of a jalapeno grilled cheese being pulled apart.

How Lengthy Will My Grilled Cheese Final?

That is a kind of dishes that’s greatest loved instantly. What makes a jalapeno popper grilled cheese so good is the nice and cozy, crispy bread and melty goodness on the within!

If you must, you may retailer your sandwich in an hermetic container within the fridge for as much as 24 hours. Reheat on the range to get it tasting heat and crispy once more! Needless to say the longer your grilled cheese sits, the extra soggy the bread will develop into because the cream cheese combination seeps into it.

Closeup of jalapeno popper grilled cheese sandwiches.

Want Extra Jalapeno Popper Recipes in Your Life? Strive These!

Jalapeno Popper Dip

prep 10 minutes cook dinner 20 minutes complete 30 minutes

Jalapeño Popper Hen

prep 15 minutes cook dinner 45 minutes complete 1 hour

Creamy Jalapeño Dip

prep 5 minutes complete 5 minutes


  • Preheat the oven to broil. Place the entire jalapenos on a baking sheet then drizzle with olive oil. Broil for 5-6 minutes turning midway by. Watch the jalapenos intently, they could broil faster relying in your oven.

  • Place the roasted jalapenos in a ziplock bag to “sweat” for five minutes.

  • Take away the pores and skin and minimize every jalapeno in half lengthwise. Discard the seeds.

  • In a medium bowl, mix the cream cheese, inexperienced onion, and garlic powder.

  • Unfold the cream cheese combination on one aspect of all 4 slices of bread.

  • Prime two of the slices with shredded cheese, and the opposite two slices with bacon and roasted jalapenos.

  • Rigorously shut the sandwich and butter the highest slice of bread. Add a sprinkle of garlic salt and Italian seasoning in the event you want.

  • Warmth a big nonstick skillet over medium warmth. Place the buttered aspect down on the skillet and shortly butter and season the topside.

  • Prepare dinner for about 4 minutes per aspect. Flip the warmth down if the skin begins to brown too shortly. Low and sluggish is the important thing to melted the cheese and never getting the skin too darkish.



Serves: 2

Serving1sandwichEnergy1201kcal (60%)Carbohydrates35g (12%)Protein39g (78%)Fats101g (155%)Saturated Fats53g (265%)Polyunsaturated Fats7gMonounsaturated Fats33gTrans Fats1gLdl cholesterol241mg (80%)Sodium1517mg (63%)Potassium451mg (13%)Fiber3g (12%)Sugar7g (8%)Vitamin A2758IU (55%)Vitamin C26mg (32%)Calcium820mg (82%)Iron3mg (17%)

All dietary data relies on third occasion calculations and is barely an estimate. Every recipe and dietary worth will fluctuate relying on the manufacturers you utilize, measuring strategies and portion sizes per family.

Course Dinner, lunch

Delicacies American

Key phrase jalapeno popper grilled cheese, jalapeno popper grilled cheese recipe



LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Read More

Recent